Quercus (Canvas) Discussions allows instructors and students to exchange ideas, ask questions, and engage in asynchronous conversations within a course. Instructors can create graded or ungraded discussions, organize conversations for the entire class or smaller groups, and configure participation and access settings.
Discussions can support collaborative learning, reflection, critical thinking, and engagement with different perspectives. For broader pedagogical strategies and tool comparisons, consult CTSI’s Online Discussion Tools resource.
Designing Discussions for Learning
Before creating a discussion in Quercus, consider what students should learn through the activity, how they will interact, and what conditions will support meaningful participation.
Establishing Purpose and Participation Expectations
Purposeful discussions provide opportunities for students to develop ideas, apply course concepts, and learn through interaction with others.
When planning a discussion, consider:
- Learning purpose: Identify what students should demonstrate or develop, such as interpreting evidence, comparing perspectives, solving problems, or reflecting on their learning.
- Discussion prompts: Use questions, scenarios, or materials that invite analysis, explanation, and exchange rather than simply recalling information.
- Participation structure: Determine whether students will contribute an initial response, reply to peers, ask questions, or revisit the discussion over time.
- Quality of contributions: Explain what meaningful participation involves, including reasoning, evidence, constructive responses, and engagement with different perspectives.
- Feedback and assessment: Decide whether participation will be graded and how students will receive feedback on their contributions.
For example, rather than asking students to summarize a reading, instructors might invite them to compare interpretations, identify questions raised by the material, or apply concepts to a scenario.
When assessing participation, consider the quality of students’ contributions rather than relying only on the number or length of posts.
Supporting Accessible and Inclusive Participation
Discussion activities should account for the different ways students access materials, communicate ideas, and engage with others. Instructors can reduce barriers through intentional choices about participation requirements, formats, timing, and interaction.
Consider the following approaches:
- Establish a respectful environment: Communicate expectations for constructive disagreement, appropriate language, and engagement with different perspectives. A community agreement can help establish shared expectations.
- Provide accessible materials: Use descriptive links, alternative text for meaningful images, and captions or transcripts for audiovisual content.
- Allow time for reflection: Provide sufficient time for students to review materials, formulate responses, and return to conversations.
- Offer appropriate participation pathways: Where learning outcomes permit, allow students to communicate through text, images, links, or supported media.
- Consider discussion size: Use smaller groups or focused conversations when large discussions become difficult to navigate.
- Plan instructor presence: Establish how instructors or teaching assistants will monitor participation, address concerns, and support students who may need assistance.
Not every discussion requires the same level of structure or instructor involvement. Consider how these decisions align with the activity’s purpose, students’ needs, and available teaching resources.
Creating and Configuring Discussions
The Discussions area in Quercus allows instructors to create discussion topics, configure participation settings, and manage access. Discussions can be ungraded activities or graded assessments connected to the Gradebook.
Creating a Discussion
To create a discussion:
- Open Discussions in your Quercus course.
- Select + Discussion.
- Enter a discussion title and add instructions or prompts using the Rich Content Editor.
- Configure the relevant participation, grading, and access settings.
- Specify the intended participants and availability dates.
- Select Save to continue editing later or Save & Publish when the discussion is ready for students.
The Rich Content Editor allows instructors to include text, images, links, documents, and supported media. These can provide context, introduce discussion prompts, or present materials for students to interpret.
Review the instructions and settings before publishing, particularly when students will be required to contribute or interact with peers.
For detailed instructions, consult Canvas LMS’s How do I create a discussion as an instructor? guide.
Choosing Discussion Settings
Quercus provides several options for structuring conversations, managing participation, and configuring graded or group discussions.
- Disallow threaded replies: Restrict participants to replying to the main discussion topic rather than responding directly to other replies.
- Participants must respond to the topic before viewing other replies: Require students to contribute before accessing classmates’ responses.
- Allow liking: Enable likes for discussion replies, with an option to restrict liking to graders.
- Add to student to-do: Include an ungraded discussion in students’ to-do lists to communicate participation expectations.
- Graded: Enable grading for the discussion, including points, assessment settings, and Gradebook integration.
- This is a Group Discussion: Create separate discussion spaces for students within a selected Group Set.
Allowing threaded replies can support extended conversations and follow-up questions. Disallowing threaded replies may be more appropriate when instructors want students to respond to a common prompt without developing separate conversations.
Requiring students to post before viewing other replies can encourage independent thinking, but it may also limit opportunities to learn from classmates before contributing. Consider whether this setting supports the intended activity.
Through the Discussions settings, instructors can configure whether students may:
- Create their own discussion topics.
- Edit or delete their discussion replies.
- Attach files to discussions.
These permissions apply across the course and should reflect how students are expected to participate.
Instructors can also establish default thread display and sorting preferences, including whether students may change those settings.
Important: Once a discussion contains threaded replies, instructors cannot change the setting that disallows threaded replies. Review the intended discussion structure before students begin participating.
Note: Files attached to replies in ungraded discussions count towards students’ personal file-storage quotas, while attachments to graded discussion replies do not.
Configuring Anonymous Discussions
Quercus supports anonymous discussions, which can provide opportunities for students to ask questions, explore ideas, or contribute without displaying their identities to classmates.
Two options are available:
- Partially anonymous: Students choose whether to display their names and profile pictures when contributing.
- Fully anonymous: Student names and profile pictures are hidden in discussion contributions.
Anonymous participation may be useful for activities involving uncertainty, exploratory thinking, or questions students might hesitate to ask publicly. However, anonymity does not eliminate the need for clear expectations, respectful communication, and instructor moderation.
Important: Anonymous discussions cannot be graded or configured as group discussions. Contributions from instructors, teaching assistants, and course designers are not anonymous. Anonymous settings cannot be changed after students have begun contributing.
Instructors should explain the limitations of anonymity and avoid promising that anonymous participation provides complete privacy.
Configuring Graded Discussions
Instructors can enable Graded when creating a discussion that contributes to course assessment.
Graded discussion settings include:
- Points Possible: Specify the maximum score.
- Display Grade As: Choose an appropriate grading format, such as points, percentage, complete/incomplete, letter grade, or GPA scale.
- Assignment Group: Organize the discussion within the appropriate Gradebook assessment category.
- Peer Reviews: Require students to provide feedback on classmates’ contributions, where appropriate.
- Due dates and availability: Establish deadlines and access windows for the intended students or groups.
Graded discussions appear in the Assignments area and create a corresponding Gradebook column. Instructors can use SpeedGrader to review and evaluate student contributions.
Important: Graded discussions cannot be anonymous. When using letter grades, instructors should ensure that an appropriate University of Toronto grading scheme has been configured, since Canvas’s default grading scheme does not align with U of T’s grading scales.
For technical instructions, consult Canvas LMS’s How do I create a graded discussion? guide and CTSI’s Quercus (Canvas) Gradebook resource.
Setting Dates and Differentiated Access
Quercus allows instructors to control when discussions are available and which students can participate.
Discussion availability settings include:
- Available from: Determines when students can begin accessing the discussion for participation.
- Until: Determines when students can no longer add or edit replies. After this date, students can generally continue reading the discussion.
Graded discussions can also include a Due date that establishes the expected participation deadline. A due date does not automatically prevent students from contributing afterward; the Until date controls when participation closes.
Instructors can use the Assign To settings to make discussions available to specific students or sections, including differentiated availability dates and, for graded discussions, due dates.
This can support different participation schedules, approved extensions, or discussions intended for particular course sections.
When configuring differentiated access:
- Open the discussion and select Edit.
- Locate the Assign To settings.
- Select the intended students or sections and establish the appropriate dates.
- Add additional recipient and date configurations where necessary.
- Confirm that all intended students retain access before saving.
Important: Changes to discussion recipients can affect student access and existing contributions. Review differentiated settings carefully, particularly after students have begun participating.
When a discussion is included in a Module, the Module’s publication and access settings can also affect whether students can participate. Review both the discussion and Module settings.
Facilitating and Managing Discussions
After publishing a discussion, instructors can organize conversations, follow participation, and support productive exchanges using the Quercus Discussions interface.
Navigating and Organizing Discussions
The Discussions Index Page organizes course discussions into sections such as Pinned Discussions, Discussions, and Closed for Comments.
Instructors can use several features to manage discussions:
- Pinning: Keep important or frequently used discussions prominent.
- Searching: Locate discussion topics or search within replies.
- Sorting: Organize replies by chronological order.
- Thread views: Expand or collapse conversations and use inline or split-screen viewing.
- Read and unread indicators: Identify new activity and mark replies as read or unread.
- Closing discussions: Prevent additional replies when a conversation has concluded.
These features can help instructors navigate active discussions, particularly when there are many participants or several simultaneous conversations.
Instructors can also configure default reply sorting and thread display preferences. Where these settings are locked, students cannot change the selected view or order.
For detailed instructions, consult Canvas LMS’s How do I use the Discussions Index Page? and How do I view and sort discussion replies as an instructor? guides.
Managing Participation and Notifications
Quercus allows instructors to follow discussion activity through subscriptions and notification settings.
Instructors are automatically subscribed to discussions they create or reply to. Discussions created by students or teaching assistants may require manual subscription, and imported discussions must also be subscribed to manually.
Notifications depend on each user’s Canvas notification preferences. Subscriptions do not necessarily generate immediate notifications for every contribution.
Additional features include:
- Mentions: Direct replies to particular participants where supported.
- Quoting: Reference portions of earlier contributions when responding.
- Role labels: Distinguish instructor and teaching assistant contributions.
- Read/unread tracking: Identify discussion activity that may need attention.
Subscriptions apply to an entire discussion rather than individual reply threads and are not available for discussions within student groups.
For instructions, consult Canvas LMS’s How do I subscribe to a discussion as an instructor? guide.
Facilitating and Moderating Discussions
Facilitation supports meaningful interaction, while moderation involves maintaining participation expectations and addressing concerns that arise.
Instructors and teaching assistants can support discussions by:
- Asking follow-up questions that encourage students to explain or extend their thinking.
- Connecting contributions to course concepts, readings, or learning outcomes.
- Highlighting different perspectives and inviting further consideration.
- Clarifying misunderstandings when necessary.
- Summarizing emerging themes or identifying questions for subsequent learning activities.
- Addressing inappropriate contributions and reinforcing established participation expectations.
Quercus provides options for editing or deleting discussion contributions where authorized, managing student permissions, and closing discussions to further replies.
Instructors should communicate how discussions will be monitored and how students can raise concerns. In large courses, coordinating facilitation responsibilities among instructors and teaching assistants can help sustain participation.
Not every contribution requires an instructor response. Allowing students to respond to one another before intervening can support collaborative learning.
Supporting Group Discussions
Quercus allows instructors to organize discussions within smaller groups, creating opportunities for focused conversations and collaborative learning.
Designing Small-Group Discussions
Small-group discussions can make participation more manageable in large courses and provide opportunities for students to develop ideas through sustained interaction with a smaller number of peers.
Before creating group discussions, consider:
- Purpose: Identify how smaller conversations will support the learning outcomes.
- Group formation: Determine whether groups will be assigned, selected by students, or organized around particular topics.
- Participation expectations: Clarify whether students are expected to contribute individually, respond to peers, or develop a shared understanding.
- Group size: Consider how the number of participants may affect opportunities for interaction.
- Instructor facilitation: Plan how instructors or teaching assistants will monitor and support conversations across groups.
- Assessment: Explain whether participation will be graded and how individual contributions will be evaluated.
For example, groups might analyze different case studies, interpret assigned readings, or develop responses to a shared problem before bringing their ideas into a whole-class activity.
Creating and Managing Group Discussions
Canvas group discussions use Group Sets, which organize students into groups within a course. Each group receives a separate discussion space for the activity.
To create a group discussion:
- Create a Group Set through People, or identify an existing Group Set.
- Confirm that students have been assigned to groups within the Group Set.
- Open Discussions and create or edit a discussion.
- Enable This is a Group Discussion.
- Select the appropriate Group Set.
- Configure grading, participation, and availability settings as needed.
- Save or publish the discussion.
Students participate in their assigned group’s discussion, while instructors can access the separate group conversations.
Group discussions can be graded or ungraded. When a group discussion is graded, each student’s contributions are graded individually, unlike a group assignment that may assign the same grade to all group members.
Group membership and differentiated access settings should be reviewed before publishing, particularly when only selected groups will participate.
For technical guidance, consult Canvas LMS’s How do I assign a graded discussion to a course group? guide.
Assessing Discussion Participation
Graded discussions allow instructors to evaluate student contributions while connecting discussion activities to the course’s broader assessment approach.
Reviewing and Grading Contributions
Before grading a discussion, establish what students are expected to demonstrate and communicate the assessment criteria.
Depending on the learning outcomes, instructors might evaluate:
- The relevance and clarity of contributions.
- The application of course concepts or evidence.
- The development of ideas and reasoning.
- Constructive engagement with other participants.
- Reflection, questioning, or synthesis.
The number of posts or replies may establish participation expectations, but it does not necessarily indicate the quality of students’ learning.
For graded discussions, SpeedGrader brings together an individual student’s contributions, allowing instructors to review participation without navigating the entire class conversation. Grades entered through SpeedGrader are recorded in the Gradebook, subject to the configured grading and posting settings.
For detailed instructions, consult CTSI’s Quercus (Canvas) SpeedGrader and Quercus (Canvas) Gradebook resources.
Using Rubrics and Peer Review
Rubrics can communicate expectations for meaningful participation and support consistent assessment. Criteria might address engagement with course concepts, quality of reasoning, use of evidence, or constructive interaction with peers.
Instructors can attach rubrics to graded discussions and use them in SpeedGrader to evaluate student contributions. For guidance, consult CTSI’s Quercus (Canvas) Rubrics resource.
Peer review allows students to provide feedback on another student’s discussion contribution. Instructors can assign reviewers manually or automatically for graded discussions.
When using peer review:
- Establish clear criteria or prompts to guide constructive feedback.
- Explain when reviews should be completed and what students are expected to provide.
- Consider using a rubric to structure feedback.
- Allow time for students to reflect on or apply the feedback they receive.
Peer review of discussions cannot be anonymous. For group discussions, reviewers generally evaluate contributions within their assigned groups. Instructors should review reviewer allocation carefully when configuring group-based peer review.
To complete a peer review, students provide a comment or complete the assigned rubric, depending on the review configuration. Completing a peer review does not automatically award points to the reviewer. If peer review participation will contribute to assessment, instructors should establish a separate grading approach.
For technical instructions, consult Canvas LMS’s How do I use peer review discussions in a course? guide.